Real-world cases

Case study: one wording difference on the invoice and an L/C presentation refused

The bank declared the documents discrepant because the product name on the invoice differed from the L/C by one word. How to handle it and the checking process to prevent it happening again.

Mr. Dan
Mr. Dan10+ years of export experience

This is a composite, illustrative case.

What happened

A cashew exporter was being paid by sight L/C. The issuing bank declared the presented documents discrepant: the invoice described the goods as "Cashew Kernels W320", while the L/C said "Cashew Nut Kernels W320". In addition, the gross weight on the packing list differed slightly from the bill of lading.

Consequences

The bank's payment undertaking was no longer absolute. The bank asked the buyer whether they would accept the discrepancies. The buyer took the opportunity to ask for a discount because "the market is falling".

How it was handled

  • Check whether there was still time to correct the documents and present again.
  • Negotiate with the buyer to accept the discrepancies, possibly paying the discrepancy fee.

Lessons

  • The description on the invoice must match the L/C exactly.
  • Cross-check every document before presentation.
  • Have your own bank check the documents first.
  • Present early so there's time to fix problems.
  • Use AI or a checklist to compare documents, as described in the article on checking documents.