Quality clauses that protect you from unreasonable claims
Most export disputes start with the words "good quality". How to describe quality with measurable parameters, reference samples and independent inspection.
"Grade 1, export quality" is a phrase I've seen in a great many Vietnamese contracts. It sounds reassuring, but when the buyer says the goods aren't "grade 1", you have nothing to prove otherwise.
Describe quality with measurable parameters
Every industry has its own set of parameters. Choose objective ones that can be measured with a clear method:
- Agricultural products: maximum moisture, foreign matter, broken grains, size, colour, pesticide residues under the importing country's rules.
- Furniture: wood species, wood moisture, dimensions and tolerances, type of finish, formaldehyde emission standard.
- Apparel: fabric composition, weight, shrinkage, colour fastness, size chart and tolerances.
- Steel: steel grade, applicable standard (e.g. JIS, ASTM, EN), chemical composition, mechanical properties.
State the test method or applicable standard as well. "Moisture 12.5%" measured on different machines can give different results.
Use reference samples
For goods that are hard to describe in numbers, such as colour, pattern or finish, use samples approved by both sides. The contract says: the goods delivered shall conform to the sample approved on [date]; each party keeps one sealed and signed sample.
Inspection: where and by whom
- Inspection at the port of loading by an independent body, such as an international or local inspection company. This inspection certificate should be stated to be final as to quality and quantity.
- If the buyer wants inspection at destination, agree a short claim period and require a certificate from an independent body. Don't accept a report drawn up by the buyer themselves.
Damage in transit
Under most Incoterms, such as FOB, CFR and CIF, the risk passes to the buyer when the goods are loaded on board. State this in the contract so the buyer can't blame you for damage in transit, and direct them to the insurer.