Governing law and disputes: courts or arbitration?
When an overseas buyer doesn't pay, where do you sue, under which law, and can the judgment be enforced? Understanding the CISG, VIAC, SIAC and the New York Convention.
Many exporters leave this section blank or accept the buyer's proposal straight away. Only when a dispute arises do they discover they must go to the buyer's country, hire foreign lawyers and follow a law they don't understand.
Governing law
- Vietnamese law: good for you, but foreign buyers often won't agree.
- The buyer's law: unfavourable to you.
- The 1980 Vienna Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG): Vietnam has been a member since 2017, and so are many major trading partners. It's often a neutral choice both sides accept. Note: between parties in member states, the CISG may apply automatically unless the contract excludes it.
- You can combine them: apply the CISG, and for matters it doesn't cover, the law of a specific country.
Courts or arbitration?
Commercial arbitration is usually preferred in international trade because:
- It's faster and confidential, and the parties can choose arbitrators with relevant expertise.
- Arbitral awards are recognised and enforced in more than 170 member states of the 1958 New York Convention, including Vietnam. Foreign court judgments are usually much harder to enforce.
Which arbitration centre?
- VIAC (Vietnam International Arbitration Centre): convenient and reasonably priced for Vietnamese companies.
- SIAC (Singapore): neutral and trusted by international buyers, but more expensive.
- Other centres such as HKIAC (Hong Kong) and the ICC.
Model clause
State the arbitration centre, its rules, the seat of arbitration, the number of arbitrators and the language. Arbitration centres publish model arbitration clauses on their websites; use them word for word to avoid the clause being invalid because of vague wording.
In practice
For small orders, arbitration costs can exceed the amount in dispute. That's why prevention through safe payment terms remains the most important protection.